The baker’s routine gestures: a professional ‘classic’?
When watching a baker kneading dough, putting loaves in the oven, taking them out and then putting them on display, we can’t help but recognise his gestures as universal, inextricably linked for us to the idea we have of his profession. And yet… for decades, bread has been produced in factories where workers no longer “put their hands in the dough” but dedicate themselves to using machines.
How is it possible that films that represent contemporary life still show images of these gestures as if they were still part of the essence of breadmaking today despite being rare in reality? And above all: How is it possible that these bakers are not perceived as relics of a bygone era, yet still seem relevant today? In both films mentioned, these professional techniques lend the protagonists a certain authority; their professional competence earns the bakers the respect or admiration of the other characters in the film.
One could even say that these routine gestures are “classics” like in literature. As the philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer has pointed out, the special feature of classics is that they last through the ages and always remain relevant — making the baker’s gestures classics. The classic dimension of these gestures is based on several factors. Firstly, on their recognisability: every spectator will quickly recognise the gesture of kneading dough, even if they have never done it themselves or watched a professional doing it. Secondly, their essentialisation: these gestures are recognised as quintessential of the trade, regardless of the omnipresence of industrial breadmaking. Finally, their valorisation: they are considered noble skills that demonstrate an admirable know-how and deserve the respect of all bread lovers.
The question that arises is this: How have the baker’s gestures become timeless classics? For other craft practices which have also been replaced by industrialisation such as tanning or weaving this was not the case. These professions haven’t found their way into commercials or movies but instead are portrayed in documentaries as a dying breed. Why is the baking profession different?
To answer this question, we have to go back to the film “Gemma Bovery” and listen to the baker, played by Fabrice Lucchini. In a scene in the bakery, Lucchini explains to the beautiful Gemma (Gemma Arterton) while she is sensuously kneading dough: “to touch bread is to touch the earth. The original crust from which life emerged”. The classical dimension of these gestures thus refers to the connectedness with the origins of bread, the direct relationship with the earth that produces the wheat and gives us life. A relationship that we do not want to give up, at least not in our imagination Despite our knowledge of the industrial fabrication of our daily bread and the fact that being a baker still means strenuous work at night for a modest wage.
Lorenzo Bonoli is Philosopher and Senior Researcher at the Swiss Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training (SFIVET) in Lausanne.
References:
Hans-Georg Gadamer (1960/1975), Truth and Method. New York : Seabury Press.
Gemma Bovery, 2014, Anne Fontaine, Fabrice Luchini, France
La Boulangerie, 2017, Award Winning Short Film, 13min, by Luke Jin
Behind the scenes of the largest industrial bakery in France, 2015, BFMTV
Fabrice Luchini in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
© Gaumont
Fabrice Luchini and Gemma Arterton in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
Fabrice Luchini and Gemma Arterton in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
© Gaumont
The baker’s routine gestures: a professional ‘classic’?
When watching a baker kneading dough, putting loaves in the oven, taking them out and then putting them on display, we can’t help but recognise his gestures as universal, inextricably linked for us to the idea we have of his profession. And yet… for decades, bread has been produced in factories where workers no longer “put their hands in the dough” but dedicate themselves to using machines.
How is it possible that films that represent contemporary life still show images of these gestures as if they were still part of the essence of breadmaking today despite being rare in reality? And above all: How is it possible that these bakers are not perceived as relics of a bygone era, yet still seem relevant today? In both films mentioned, these professional techniques lend the protagonists a certain authority; their professional competence earns the bakers the respect or admiration of the other characters in the film.
One could even say that these routine gestures are “classics” like in literature. As the philosopher Hans-Georg Gadamer has pointed out, the special feature of classics is that they last through the ages and always remain relevant — making the baker’s gestures classics. The classic dimension of these gestures is based on several factors. Firstly, on their recognisability: every spectator will quickly recognise the gesture of kneading dough, even if they have never done it themselves or watched a professional doing it. Secondly, their essentialisation: these gestures are recognised as quintessential of the trade, regardless of the omnipresence of industrial breadmaking. Finally, their valorisation: they are considered noble skills that demonstrate an admirable know-how and deserve the respect of all bread lovers.
The question that arises is this: How have the baker’s gestures become timeless classics? For other craft practices which have also been replaced by industrialisation such as tanning or weaving this was not the case. These professions haven’t found their way into commercials or movies but instead are portrayed in documentaries as a dying breed. Why is the baking profession different?
To answer this question, we have to go back to the film “Gemma Bovery” and listen to the baker, played by Fabrice Lucchini. In a scene in the bakery, Lucchini explains to the beautiful Gemma (Gemma Arterton) while she is sensuously kneading dough: “to touch bread is to touch the earth. The original crust from which life emerged”. The classical dimension of these gestures thus refers to the connectedness with the origins of bread, the direct relationship with the earth that produces the wheat and gives us life. A relationship that we do not want to give up, at least not in our imagination Despite our knowledge of the industrial fabrication of our daily bread and the fact that being a baker still means strenuous work at night for a modest wage.
Lorenzo Bonoli is Philosopher and Senior Researcher at the Swiss Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training (SFIVET) in Lausanne.
References:
Hans-Georg Gadamer (1960/1975), Truth and Method. New York : Seabury Press.
Gemma Bovery, 2014, Anne Fontaine, Fabrice Luchini, France
La Boulangerie, 2017, Award Winning Short Film, 13min, by Luke Jin
Behind the scenes of the largest industrial bakery in France, 2015, BFMTV
Fabrice Luchini in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
© Gaumont
Fabrice Luchini and Gemma Arterton in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
Fabrice Luchini and Gemma Arterton in Gemma Bovery, 2014, France
© Gaumont
Essential Workers vs. Bullshit Jobs
How will the Covid-19 pandemic change the world of work? Will essential workers be more valued in the future or will ‘bullshit’ jobs continue to increase?
Plea for autochthone education systems
'In my blood it runs' (2019) is an intimate portrait of an Aboriginal boy and his family, as well as testimony to the glaring shortcomings of the Australian education system in dealing with their indigenous population.
Efficiency kills
US economist William J. Baumol found out why the efficiency principle is killing the service sector - and ultimately contributing to the COVID-19 mortality rate.
The unsung sing
In the second part of his trilogy about people in unsung professions, "Secondo Me" (2016), Pavel Cuzuioc accompanies three cloakroom attendants at three European opera houses and welcomes the everyday to stage.
Comparative work studies with the camera: Darcy Lange
With his camera, the artist Darcy Lange provided important scientific material on work and education, which still begs to be analysed in social and educational research.
Forced labour even after death
A capitalism-critical reading of the zombie film on the occasion of the release of Zombi Child (2019) by Bertrand Bonello.
About this blog
By selecting a film or an image, this blog literally illustrates the vast sphere of work, employment & education in an open collection of academic, artistic and also anecdotal findings.
About us
Konrad Wakolbinger makes documentary films about work and life. Jörg Markowitsch does research on education and work. They are both based in Vienna. Information on guest authors can be found in their corresponding articles.
More about
Interested in more? Find recommendations on relevant festivals, film collections and literature here.
About this blog
With picking a film or an image, this blog literally illustrates the vast sphere of work, employment & education in an open collection of academic, artistic and also anecdotal findings.
About us
Konrad Wakolbinger makes documentary films about work and life. Jörg Markowitsch does research on education and work. We both work in Vienna. Information on guest authors can be found in their respective articles.
More about
Interested in more? Find recommendations on relevant festivals, film collections and literature here.