The unsung sing
When I was visiting the University of Tallinn some time ago, it must have been shortly after Estonia’s accession to the EU, I was fascinated by the fact that there was a cloakroom there, like in a theatre, where — mostly women of a certain age — took the jackets and coats of young students. On the one hand there was this feeling of opulence in a supposedly less than well-off country, on the other hand there was this immediately tangible inequality. The social participation and simple presence of the older generation in the direct support of the younger ones seemed like something anachronistic.
The conversations between the cloakroom attendant and retiree Nadezhda Sokhtskaya, with her colleague at their workplace in the Odessa Opera House, documented in the film “Secondo Me” (2016) by Pavel Cuzuioc, made exactly this impression on me. The other two protagonists of the film, Flavio Fornasa in the cloakroom of the Teatro La Scala in Milan and Ronald Zwanziger in the Vienna State Opera, are their counterparts, and yet markedly different.
Flavio is in his mid-fifties, studied at the Technical University of Milan and is a full-time safety inspector for the Italian National Railway Company. The search for an additional part-time job led him to La Scala, where he first became a safety officer, then a ticket inspector and finally, since 2003, a cloakroom attendant.
Ronald, just over seventy, has a doctorate in Indo-Germanic Studies and was a full-time librarian at the library of the University of Vienna. For three decades, however, he has also been working as a cloakroom attendant at the Vienna State Opera in the evening.
The film vividly depicts the everyday life of the three cloakroom attendants, their work, leisure and family time. It shows them in the gym, in the nail studio, visiting a dolphin show with the grandchildren, playing chess with the children, cooking, eating and swimming. What is performed on stage at the respective opera houses remains behind closed doors and only occasionally reminds us that it’s there when the upholstered doors are opened. The stage that the film offers actually belongs exclusively to the three cloakroom attendants. Their small curtained kiosks look like miniature versions of the main stages of these famous houses — the cloakroom as an allegory of the world stage.
Flavio, who is about to say goodbye to his work forever, sums it up as if he were the chief executive of the opera house and not a simple background employee: “All in all, when I think of my time at La Scala, I wouldn’t do anything different […] basically I liked it here, I was happy.”
Professions where we find it difficult to see them as a valid vocation, and people who seem invisible to us and to whom we generally pay no attention, are in the focus of Moldavian-born and Vienna-based filmmaker Pavel Cuzuioc. His tributes to professional and everyday life bring social inequalities into perspective and show that the great can also be found in the supposedly insignificant, the simple, and that the former can’t work without the latter.
References:
Cuzuioc, Pavel (O.D), SECONDO ME, Presseheft (retrieved 5.10.2020)
pavelcuzuioc.com
SECONDO ME, Pavel Cuzuioc, 2016, Austria, Trailer
Nadezhda Sokhatskaya, Odessa Opera House, Filmstill
© Michael Schindegger, PAVEL CUZUIOC FILMPRODUKTION
Flavio Fornasa – La Scala, Milan. Filmstill
© Michael Schindegger, PAVEL CUZUIOC FILMPRODUKTION
The unsung sing
When I was visiting the University of Tallinn some time ago, it must have been shortly after Estonia’s accession to the EU, I was fascinated by the fact that there was a cloakroom there, like in a theatre, where — mostly women of a certain age — took the jackets and coats of young students. On the one hand there was this feeling of opulence in a supposedly less than well-off country, on the other hand there was this immediately tangible inequality. The social participation and simple presence of the older generation in the direct support of the younger ones seemed like something anachronistic.
The conversations between the cloakroom attendant and retiree Nadezhda Sokhtskaya, with her colleague at their workplace in the Odessa Opera House, documented in the film “Secondo Me” (2016) by Pavel Cuzuioc, made exactly this impression on me. The other two protagonists of the film, Flavio Fornasa in the cloakroom of the Teatro La Scala in Milan and Ronald Zwanziger in the Vienna State Opera, are their counterparts, and yet markedly different.
Flavio is in his mid-fifties, studied at the Technical University of Milan and is a full-time safety inspector for the Italian National Railway Company. The search for an additional part-time job led him to La Scala, where he first became a safety officer, then a ticket inspector and finally, since 2003, a cloakroom attendant.
Ronald, just over seventy, has a doctorate in Indo-Germanic Studies and was a full-time librarian at the library of the University of Vienna. For three decades, however, he has also been working as a cloakroom attendant at the Vienna State Opera in the evening.
The film vividly depicts the everyday life of the three cloakroom attendants, their work, leisure and family time. It shows them in the gym, in the nail studio, visiting a dolphin show with the grandchildren, playing chess with the children, cooking, eating and swimming. What is performed on stage at the respective opera houses remains behind closed doors and only occasionally reminds us that it’s there when the upholstered doors are opened. The stage that the film offers actually belongs exclusively to the three cloakroom attendants. Their small curtained kiosks look like miniature versions of the main stages of these famous houses — the cloakroom as an allegory of the world stage.
Flavio, who is about to say goodbye to his work forever, sums it up as if he were the chief executive of the opera house and not a simple background employee: “All in all, when I think of my time at La Scala, I wouldn’t do anything different […] basically I liked it here, I was happy.”
Professions where we find it difficult to see them as a valid vocation, and people who seem invisible to us and to whom we generally pay no attention, are in the focus of Moldavian-born and Vienna-based filmmaker Pavel Cuzuioc. His tributes to professional and everyday life bring social inequalities into perspective and show that the great can also be found in the supposedly insignificant, the simple, and that the former can’t work without the latter.
References:
Cuzuioc, Pavel (O.D), SECONDO ME, Presseheft (retrieved 5.10.2020)
pavelcuzuioc.com
SECONDO ME, Pavel Cuzuioc, 2016, Austria, Trailer
Nadezhda Sokhatskaya, Odessa Opera House, Filmstill
© Michael Schindegger, PAVEL CUZUIOC FILMPRODUKTION
Flavio Fornasa – La Scala, Milan. Filmstill
© Michael Schindegger, PAVEL CUZUIOC FILMPRODUKTION
Comparative work studies with the camera: Darcy Lange
With his camera, the artist Darcy Lange provided important scientific material on work and education, which still begs to be analysed in social and educational research.
Forced labour even after death
A capitalism-critical reading of the zombie film on the occasion of the release of Zombi Child (2019) by Bertrand Bonello.
Society without connection
The new film "Please hold the line" (2020) by Pavel Cuzuioc loosely follows the work of service technicians in the telecommunications industry in the far east of Europe while actually portraying their customers more. Those who are in danger of losing their connection to society.
Forklift-Conflicts
In the Aisles (2018) by Thomas Stuber is the ultimate warehouse-worker feature film. There has never been so much 'workplace' featured in a movie, set in a wholesale market, with so much insight into learning the ropes of an unskilled job. On top of that, romance.
Korea’s Generation Internship 4.0
The TV series "Misaeng: Incomplete Life" gives deep insights into South-Korea's working world and the difficult transition to get there.
